Who wins this fantasy baseball trade?

depends if sizemore returns from injury and hughes has a breakout season. I dont see either heppening this season. Hughes is likely to wear down this year. He's practically one of two quality yankee startes so he'll pitch a ton of innings. Ibanez is 38 and he had a solid year last year so he could have another okay year, especially since theres not a ton of depth behind him. On the other side, ethier was a triple crown candidate for the first 3 months or so and he should have another really good seaason. Guitierez was a disapointment but he's young and has a lot of potential and room to improve. Lastly, Burnett is washed up I think, he has not done anything the past 2-3 years but get injured and have an ERA higher than his total strikeouts. I go with getting Ethier and Guitierez and Burnett sinze there is more potential there.